The digital magazine of New York indie theater
Loading
This Isn't Working
nytheatre.com review by Sharon Fogarty
August 15, 2005
Talented writer Francesco Marciuliano, author of the nationally syndicated
comic strips Sally Forth and Medium Large (available weekdays at
www.DrinkatWork.com), has gathered some
of the best comic actors I’ve seen in a while to present his four short plays,
or long sketches, about job dissatisfaction. The works, for me, are more true
than funny, as each piece rides essentially on one joke, though Marciuliano’s
one-liners, clever comebacks, and deep wit do point to a very gifted satirist.The subject of corporate surreality is central to each work and most evident
in the first piece, “The Island,” which features five office workers who, having
survived a plane crash, are stranded on a desert island. In suits torn to
shreds, the starving survivors attempt to continue with their “team meetings”
and carry on with “business as usual.” Marciuliano wonderfully conveys that
corporate tactics, abstract solutions which look good on paper, never quite get
underway or focus on who is actually going to do the dirty work.Despite the one-joke issue, the actors carry the plays splendidly,
particularly when Miranda Jonte and Megan Ross battle it out in “The Awards,”
about a ceremony for best pharmaceutical commercial copy. The joke of running
back to the microphone to either gain self praise or further insult each other
is repeated excessively, but the actresses are completely inspired each time and
the work becomes entertaining because of their oddly manic determination. The
two other sketches in the program are “The Meeting,” where an author has the
power to write events and characters in and out of his life, and “The Takeover,”
in which Neanderthals are being bought out of existence by a more advanced race.Under Jefferson Jowdy’s direction, Marciuliano’s works fall somewhere between
a Saturday Night Live sketch and a Twilight Zone episode; they
seem to either need more action to become plays or crude editing to become
sketches. But the actors handle this delicately and should be commended. They
include Alex Goldberg, who carries a sublime sincerity in each of his complex
roles, and Julia Garrett and Will Bouvier who, with their honest and calming
presence, are well cast as the voices of truth amidst corporate blindness. The
corporate-ladder-climbing roles are played with hilarious arrogance by Michaela
Hall, Gary Culig, and David Flaherty. Peter Rodriguez and Barbara Drum Sullivan
create a series of exceptional performances, leaping into their characters with
complete abandon, heightening the ridiculous circumstances of each scene, and
often getting huge laughs because of their serious commitment.